Elliot Norton Awards:
- 2023 Outstanding Solo Performance — Paul Melendy, The Legend of Sleepy Hollow
- 2023 Outstanding Musical Production — Ain’t Misbehavin’
- 2023 Outstanding Featured Performance in a Musical — Anthony Pires, Jr., Ain’t Misbehavin’
- 2023 Outstanding Musical Direction — David Freeman Coleman and Dan Rodriguez, Ain’t Misbehavin’
- 2022 Outstanding Musical Production — All is Calm: The Christmas Truce of 1914
- 2020 Outstanding Choreography – Ilyse Robbins, Swan Lake in Blue
- 2014 Outstanding Director of a Musical — Ilyse Robbins, Thoroughly Modern Millie
- 2008 Outstanding Actress, Small/Midsize Company — Rachel Harker, The Cutting
IRNE (Independent Reviewers of New England) Awards:
- 2018 Best Choreography, Small Theatre — Ilyse Robbins, Dames at Sea
- 2018 Best Actor in a Midsize Play, Small Theatre — Thomas Derrah, Gabriel
- 2018 Best Supporting Actor in a Musical, Small Theatre — Jared Troilo, She Loves Me
- 2018 Best Director of a Musical, Small Theatre — Ilyse Robbins, She Loves Me
- 2018 Promising Young Performer, Small Theatre — Marissa Simeqi, Gabriel
- 2016 Best Choreography, Small Theatre — Ilyse Robbins, How To Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- 2012 Best Choreography, Small Theatre — Ilyse Robbins, 42nd Street
- 2010 Best Costumes, Small Theatre — Stacey Stephens, My Fair Lady
- 2009 Best Sound Design, Small Theatre — Nathan Leigh, Strangers on a Train
- 2007 Best Visiting Production, Small Theatre — George M. Cohan Tonight
- 2005 Best Actress in a Musical, Small Theatre — Leigh Barrett, Pal Joey
- 2004 Best Actor in a Play, Small Theatre — Neil A. Casey, The Dazzle
New England Theatre Conference (NETC) Award:
2014 Regional Award Recipient for Excellence in Theatre
North Shore Magazine:
2015 Best of the North Shore (BONS),
Editor’s Choice for Live Theatre Venue
Boston Business Journal:
Named Greater Boston Stage Company one of the top 5 largest performing arts organizations
(based on annual attendance) in the Boston area in their 2 most recent surveys.
Boston Parent’s Paper:
2014 and 2015 Family Favorite Top 5 for Live Theatre